je leest...
Geen categorie

Obama, ISIS, Kissinger and Clausewitz: American Military Force in Religious Conflicts

Source: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/richard-brodsky/obama-isis-kissinger-and_b_5788136.html

Richard Brodsky
Senior Fellow, Demos

Posted: 09/09/2014 7:59 am EDT Updated: 09/09/2014 9:59 am EDT

It took Henry Kissinger to articulate the sense of chaos and anarchic violence that is spreading across the world: The World Order is crumbling. Beheadings, mass murder of civilians, international borders vanishing, and the inability of political institutions to manage conflict are smashing the carefully constructed post-WWII universe.

There’s a reason, and historical precedent, and neither bodes well for a swift return to manageable conflicts.

Humanity’s recent efforts to reduce war and violence have been based on the faith that political institutions could contain and mitigate violence. Two hundred years ago Clausewitz shrewdly defined war as”politics by other means.” We could negotiate and politic our way out of war, if we were smart about it. We reversed Clausewitz and successfully used politics as “war by other means.”

But it’s a rationalist, somewhat Western model. And it is no longer accepted in many quarters.

Rationalist goals have receded and been replaced by religious goals in crucial regions of conflict. There is little one can negotiate with an opponent whose actions spring from the absolute certainty and spiritual requirements of religion. Take the obvious transformation of the Palestinian/Israeli conflict. Once was, the conflict was between two competing secular visions, Zionism and Palestinian autonomy. Now Hamas presents an Islamist vision of the struggle, and the old PLO secularists are sidelined. Although much less profound, Israeli politics have a similar transformation, with questions about the power of religious settlers for whom loss of any part of Israeli territory is a religious sin.

It’s happened before. The Crusades, the Inquisition and the French Religious Wars centuries ago. The recent Sudanese, Nigerian and Lebanese civil wars. And now ISIS with its murderous vision of a Sunni Islamist Caliphate, the consequent butchery of Muslims and others, and the de facto end to national borders created by Western colonial powers. Negotiations are not going to settle our differences with ISIS.

Obama’s strength has been a keen intellectual grasp of issues and a willingness to reduce the use of force even when he is criticized as weak. It’s kinda worked, with the quantum of violence in Iraq, Afghanistan and elsewhere reduced, all very much in the national interest. That strength could now be a weakness. Whether on our own or in concert with others force and violence are the only available tools, other than doing nothing and hoping for the best.

There is an argument for doing nothing. ISIS will heighten the Sunni/Shiite/Alawite split in Islam. Old enemies, like the US and Iran, will have common interests. Sunni kingdoms will worry about ISIS expanding. Israel could revive a political relationship with the PLO.

All risky and unlikely. Obama now faces a transformation of his signature policies that reduced violence as a tool of foreign policy. He will have no allies in the anti-Obama crowd whose desire to see him fail often outstrips their pursuit of the national interest. He is being tested and he is alone.

A new international paradigm is upon us. Kissinger, the foreign policy establishment and the rationalists see it coming but don’t know what to do. It’s up to Obama, for better or worse, to develop a doctrine and a methodology for the use of force in religious conflicts. It will likely be the most lasting of his strategic contributions to the national interest.

Follow Richard Brodsky on Twitter: http://www.twitter.com/richardbrodsky


Over ariannelot

"Hidden manna from the promised "White Stone", Rev 2:17 P1446:5, 131:3.3 . . . It is evil to see sin where there is no sin; TO SEE NO SIN WHERE THERE IS SIN. Evil is the path of FALSE DOCTRINES. Those who avoid evil BY SEEING THINGS AS THEY ARE gain joy by thus embracing the truth. Make an end of your misery BY LOATHING SIN. When you look up to the Noble One, turn away from sin with a whole heart. Make no apology for evil; MAKE NO EXCUSE FOR SIN. By your efforts to make amends for past sins you acquire strength to resist future tendencies thereto. Restraint is born of repentance. Leave no fault unconfessed to the Noble One. 131:3.4 (1447.1) “Cheerfulness and gladness are the rewards of deeds well done and to the glory of the Immortal. No man can rob you of the liberty of your own mind. When the faith of your religion has emancipated your heart, when the mind, like a mountain, is settled and immovable, then shall the peace of the soul flow tranquilly like a river of waters. Those who are sure of salvation are forever free from lust, envy, hatred, and the delusions of wealth. While faith is the energy of the better life, nevertheless, must you work out your own salvation with perseverance. If you would be certain of your final salvation, then make sure that you sincerely seek to fulfill all righteousness. Cultivate the assurance of the heart which springs from within and thus come to enjoy the ecstasy of eternal salvation. ~~ Urantia Book Paper 131 ~~


Nog geen reacties

Geef een reactie

Vul je gegevens in of klik op een icoon om in te loggen.

WordPress.com logo

Je reageert onder je WordPress.com account. Log uit /  Bijwerken )

Google+ photo

Je reageert onder je Google+ account. Log uit /  Bijwerken )


Je reageert onder je Twitter account. Log uit /  Bijwerken )

Facebook foto

Je reageert onder je Facebook account. Log uit /  Bijwerken )


Verbinden met %s



Voer je e-mailadres in om deze blog te volgen en om per e-mail meldingen over nieuwe berichten te ontvangen.

Doe mee met 3 andere volgers

International Red Alert System

Alerting The World Now!!

altruism in the 21th century

.....a prerequisite for survival as humanity

Ronmamita's Blog

Creatively Express Freedom

Yanis Varoufakis


The McClaughry's Blog

This is the place



Higher Density Blog

Love Is Always The Answer

Political Vel Craft

Veil Of Politics

Der Honigmann sagt...

Der etwas andere weblog...

wall of controversy

the other side of the story

the enigma channel


Friends of Syria

revealing the truth

Transform Now Plowshares

They will hammer their swords into plowshares

The Tonka Report

Real News In A Changing World

| truthaholics

Exposing Truth Behind Media Spin

Transhumanist Agenda War Crimes Tribunal

"Deconstructing the Transhumanist Agenda"

UZA - a people's court of conscience

a jural assembly by, for and of the people

Freedom Documents

documents from sovereigns on how to attain freedom- Not legal advice-just what has worked for others


We don’t brake for Langley S*** Dragon. We don’t brake for pumpkin-f***ers either.


Milabs, Monarchs, Human Cloning


For a greater understanding of the encultured brain and body...

%d bloggers liken dit: